Arcade Roms bei ebay

[Pantokrator]

bei ebay England werden Arcade Collections mit über 5000 Spielen verkauft. Es wird sogar extra als MAME Arcade beworben. Ist der Verkauf ohne die entsprechenden PCBs in England erlaubt?

[prc69]

Soll das ne ernst gemeinte Frage sein???? Copyright ist Copyright ... nein, das ist nicht erlaubt. Wie und ob das in manchen Ländern verfolgt wird ist eine andere Frage, allein die Behandlung durch eBay unterscheidet sich signifikant.

PS: In den Lizenzbedingungen von Mame und den meisten anderen Emulatoren steht ganz klar, dass diese ohne Ausdrückliche Genehmigung gar nicht verkauft werden dürfen, schon gar nicht in Verbindung mit ROMs. Bei Mame ist sogar der Einsatz im kommerziellen Bereich verboten, da halten sich aber hier in D auch nicht alle dran ... Burn in hell, kann ich da nur sagen ... :evil:

[prc69]

Hier mal die Q&As von Mame, keine Ahnung, warum solche Fragen wie deine überhaupt gestellt werden, wo die Lage doch so klar ist ... Ich glaube das Unrechtsbewusstsein hört bei Software generell auf. Scheinbar ist allgemein das Gefühl, dass alles was umsonst ist, auch beliebig verwurstet werden darf sehr verbreitet ...


Q. Can I include MAME with my product?
A. No. MAME is not licensed (http://mamedev.org/legal.html#license) for commercial use. Using MAME as a "freebie" or including it at "no cost" with your product still constitutes commerical usage and is forbidden by the license (http://mamedev.org/legal.html#license).

Q. Can I sell my product with the MAME logo on it?
A. No. Putting the logo on your product makes it appear that the product is something officially endorsed by Nicola Salmoria, and constitutes trademark (http://mamedev.org/legal.html#trademark) infringement.

Q. Can I use the MAME logo to advertise my product?
A. No. Using the logo in your advertising makes it appear that the product is something officially endorsed by Nicola Salmoria, and constitutes trademark (http://mamedev.org/legal.html#trademark) infringement.

Q. Can I use the term "MAME" in the name of my software?
A. Generally, no, especially if it is something that is sold. However, if you are producing a free MAME-related piece of software, it is common that permission is granted. Send a query (http://mamedev.org/contact.html) to double- check first, please.

Q. Can I put an arcade cabinet running MAME in a public location?
A. No. This this a commercial use of MAME and is prohibited by the license (http://mamedev.org/legal.html#license). Even if you don't charge money, putting a machine in a public location is "operating" an arcade machine and falls under commercial rules in most locations.

Q. Can my non-profit use MAME or an arcade cabinet running MAME to help raise money?
A. No, sorry. Even for the most worthwhile cause, this still is a commercial use of MAME and is prohibited by the license (http://mamedev.org/legal.html#license).

Q. How do I obtain a license to the MAME source code?
A. You can't. See the Copyright (http://mamedev.org/legal.html#copyright) section above.

Q. Is it legal to download ROMs for a game when I own the PCB?
A. This is unclear and depends on where you live. In most cases you would need to obtain permission from the original manufacturer to do so.

Q. What about the free ROMs on the MAME site? Can I use those with my product?
A. Almost all of the free ROMs on the MAME site are licensed only for non- commercial use, and only for distribution from the MAME site. Just because they are available for "free" here does not grant further redistribution rights, nor does it allow you to treat them as "freebies" for commercial use.

Q. If I obtain a license from an original manufacturer to distribute the ROMs can I use MAME to run them?
A. Generally, no, because it constitutes a commercial use of MAME. However, we have in the past made a couple of exceptions for this particular case. We will not consider making any further exceptions without proof that such a license has already been obtained.

Q. Can I use a PC running MAME to replace a real arcade PCB?
A. In order to do this you would have to use a copy of the original ROMs, which would require obtaining permission from the original manufacturer. Once you had permission from them, if it was used for non-commercial purposes, then you would not technically be violating the MAME license. However we still do not explicitly give permission to use MAME in this way because of the possibility of the game being sold sometime later, which would constitute commercial use of MAME. If you sell your game later you must sell it without MAME included.

[Laschek]

Das bringt die Emulator-Gemeinde in Verruf.

Ich frag mich da immer wieviele von denen die bei solchen Angeboten mit dem Finger zeigen selber das Copyright treten indem sie Roms horten die sie zwar nicht gekauft aber illegal runtergeladen haben...

EDIT: was'n hier grad passiert??? Da fehlen doch Beiträge?

[speleo_de]

Der Beitrag von prc69 sagt alles -> Das ist illegal.

Und .... Links auf ROMs sources sind hier nicht erlaubt.

Diverse Beiträge entfernt u.a. solche mit ROM links und Topic closed.